The effect of the squareness of the plasma boundary shape on the plasma response to the applied n = 2 (n is the toroidal mode number) resonant magnetic perturbation, and consequently on controlling the edge-localized mode (ELM) in MAST-U in the double-null configuration, is numerically systematically investigated. The modeling is performed utilizing three different plasma response models: the single-fluid model, the two-fluid model and the magnetohydrodynamic-kinetic hybrid model. The effect of the plasma squareness on ELM control is found to depend on the equilbrium kinetic profiles. Fixing the equilibrium radial profiles to that from a recent MAST-U discharge, the experimental plasma shape is found to be close to optimal for ELM control in terms of squareness. The optimal coil phasing does not significantly vary with varying plasma squareness. These findings robustly hold with (i) two figures of merit (FoMs) defined for predicting the ELM control feasibility, and (ii) three plasma response models employed for evaluating these FoMs.