Edge localized modes (ELMs) are magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) instabilities that cause fast periodic relaxations of the strong edge pressure gradient in tokamak fusion plasmas. Magnetic pick-up coils allow the extraction of toroidal mode numbers n during the ELM cycle including the nonlinear crash on ASDEX Upgrade, providing a good comparability to nonlinear 3D MHD codes. This paper investigates how the mode numbers before and during the ELM crash change with a variation of plasma parameters. It is found that the toroidal structure size during the crash is similar to the one existing slightly before and always has a low n = 1–7 range. Furthermore, in the nonlinear phase of the ELM n does not show a clear trend with most peeling-ballooning relevant parameters such as normalized pressure gradient, bootstrap current density or triangularity, whereas a strong decrease of n with edge safety factor q95 is observed in agreement with nonlinear modeling in the here investigated high collisionality region. A simple geometric model is presented, which is capable of explaining the q scaling by existence of ballooned structures that minimize n.